Top Bar
Musique Machine Logo Home ButtonReviews ButtonArticles ButtonBand Specials ButtonAbout Us Button
SearchGo Down
Search for  
With search mode in section(s)
And sort the results by
show articles written by  
 Review archive:  # a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

Crass - Yes Sir, I Will [Crass Records/ Southern Records - 2011]

“Yes Sir, I Will” was the forth & last ‘official’ album by revolutionary Anarcho-punk/experimental collective Crass. The album originally appeared back in 1983, and it saw the band releasing an continuous & mainly free–form improv punk track spread over two sides of vinyl.  This new reissue brings together a re-master of the original album, along with a second disc that features a  jazz/ noise remix of the album from 2002. And as with all the other reissues in this great series of classic Crass albums the set also includes: a 64 page booklet featuring essays by key members, artwork and lyrics, and a fold poster/ representation of the original vinyl packaging.

With-out a doubt this is the most experimental, difficult and least approachable of all of Crass’s back catalogue. The original album featured a mainly free-flowing improv punk track in two parts. The track found lead male singer Steve Ignorant, and female singers Joy De Vivre & Eve Libertine shouting/ speaking drummer Peni Rimbaud’s  long form  anti Falkland war poem. The backing was a mixture of shredding, smashing, chugging and bashing freeform anarcho punk. It's far from an easy listening experience, but it does really focuses the bands intelligent yet angered & nihilistic take on the punk  into a searing,hopless and unforgiving form

From time to time the sliding 'n' shifting sonic chaos does break for a few more musical moments. The first of these more comes about five minutes into the albums runtime as the band drop into  an almost 70 tinged singer-songwriter moment with poppy piano chops, synthetic string work,   male spoken word elements & layered male harmonies….this hangs around for three or so minutes then we’re back into the chaos once more. And the other main more musical moment comes around the 11 minute mark when the band home in on a more focused & memorable Anarcho punk stomp ‘n’ pogo structure . Both ‘musical’ moments make a nice break from the intensity of both Rimbaud’s words and the crude, jerking  & free-form musical punk attack.  All told “Yes Sir, I Will”  is a very challenging track, and you can see why a lot of long time fans deserted the band, but for me it’s a interestingly suffocating & jarring slice of experimental punk based music, & it’s a pity the band did'nt try going further down this path.


The Second disc in the set is taken up by the 2002 remix of the album which is fittingly subtitled “Why Don’t You Fuck Off?”. As well as been a little more noise bound yet slightly more controlled, this remix also adds in the following sonic textures: tenor & Alto Sax( by Ingrid Laubrock  whose worked with the likes of Sol6,Tom Rainey Trio, and  Crass off shoot Crass Agenda),Upright bass & bass clarinet( by Julian Siegel whose only really worked on his own stuff & Crass Agenda stuff). The remix, and the added sonic textures give the more instense and free-form punk elements of the track more focus, detail and depth. Also some of the spoken word elements seem to have been made a little more clear and powerful than the original albums mix too. On the whole I think it’s a very worthy, and enjoyable re-take/ remix on the original album, and it gives the whole piece quite a different edge/ feel.

All told this is another great reissue that clearly had a lot of time & love poured into it. Certainly this is not the album to start with if your new to Crass, but if you’ve already picked up the other great releases in this reissue series and you like the bands more noisy & free form moments you get a lot out of this.

Rating: 4 out of 5Rating: 4 out of 5Rating: 4 out of 5Rating: 4 out of 5Rating: 4 out of 5

Roger Batty
Latest Reviews

Crass - Yes Sir, I Will
“Yes Sir, I Will” was the forth & last ‘official’ album by revolutionary Anarcho-punk/experimental collective Crass. The album originally appeare...
030226   Leslie Butler - Ja-Gan
020226   Libido - Libido( Blu Ray)
020226   Night of the Juggler - Night ...
020226   Periode - Grapes of Nothingness
020226   Invictus - Nocturnal Visions
300126   Eldritch Priest - Dead-Wall R...
300126   Jürg Frey - Je Laisse à La ...
290126   The Assassination Bureau - T...
280126   Spent Stiletto/ No Fun Harsh ...
280126   Evil Damn - Eons of Horror
Latest Articles

Crude ‘n’ Hope-corroding Wall...
Back in 2024, I got my first taste of Absurd Reality, and I was so impressed by how crude and nasty its take on walled noise was. Behind the project is South...
290126   Crude ‘n’ Hope-corroding ...
231225   Creepy Images Books - Killer Art
221225   Best Of 2025 - Music, Sound &...
041225   The Spectral Sounds of The Pr...
281025   Michael Hurst Interview - Unb...
071025   Xiphos - The Rise And Fall Of...
030925   Third Window Films - A Label ...
130825   HNW fest- Barcelona- 12th Apr...
250725   Raté interview - Walled-in F...
180625   Matthew Holmes - Of razor-sha...
Go Up
(c) Musique Machine 2001 -2025. Twenty four years of true independence!! Mail Us at questions=at=musiquemachine=dot=comBottom