Top Bar
Musique Machine Logo Home ButtonReviews ButtonArticles ButtonBand Specials ButtonAbout Us Button
SearchGo Down
Search for  
With search mode in section(s)
And sort the results by
show articles written by  
 Review archive:  # a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

Paul Bley Trio - Closer [ESP-Disk - 2013]

This is one of ESP-DISK’s fiftieth anniversary remasters - and one which I arrive at with no previous knowledge or expectations. The name Paul Bley rings a bell, as does Steve Swallow, and one of the pieces is an Ornette Coleman composition (though, again, not one I recognise); but thats the extent of my knowledge here. So, we have Bley on piano, Swallow on bass and Barry Altschul on percussion; performing ten pieces in 1965, only three of which pass the three-minute mark. Rather than being headlong bursts of freneticism, these short works are actually concise, often unhurried and reserved, performances.

As I said above, most of the ten tracks are between two and three minutes in length, which is unusual for modern jazz. Indeed, there are quite a few pieces which are simply: “theme, short exploration, theme reprised”. The first track, “Ida Lupino” even dispenses with this “short exploration” and simply cycles the theme; building and falling with variations. But the overall playing can essentially be divided into two camps: twitchy, knotty pieces, or more languid, reflective ones. In both modes, the piano dominates - both in terms of playing and, alas, recording. Although “Closer” never tries to be thundering free jazz - though it does cook up a storm in places - a lot of the piano and drum work, in particular, features torrents of notes and strokes. Pieces like “Start” and “Crossroads” open with furious sections from Bley, but always with a firm sense of melody and rhythm: there’s a definite calculated restraint on display. On “Batterie”, this restraint is taken to extremes, with Bley’s discordant piano bursting in and out - almost as if the engineer was flicking the desk faders up and down. Where the trio’s restraint translates into more reflective states, the pieces often still maintain a “twitchy-ness”, a “wired-ness” - though parts of “Closer” (the track) achieve a kind of dreamy, “ambient” jazz. At the other extreme, the last piece, “Cartoon”, sounds indeed like a cartoon - with stop/start riffs and manic playing. Here, the greater energy and volume allow the drums to be properly heard; with the low-fidelity nature of the recordings finally working in the trio’s favour.

Whilst I like a fair amount of jazz, its not something I’m well-versed in; so I tend to find the freer side of things easier to digest. More than anything else, I tend to gravitate towards the rhythm section and in that respect, “Closer” isn’t too generous - Bley’s piano dominating affairs, even on headphones. The bass fares worst, often being felt more than heard; whilst the headphones reveal drums in the right channel and then echoing in the left channel… There are quite a few sections where Swallow and Altschul are allowed to run free as a duo (“Violin”, for example), but a more sympathetic recording would have been revealing. Swallow’s bass work is often essentially lost and thus hard to comment on; but Altschul’s drums, where given audio space, sound interesting indeed. Since this is a remastering, its quite intriguing as to what the original release sounded like..! This isn’t an album I imagine I’ll return to much - though this is more to do with my jazz interests than its quality - but I do admire its conciseness; a rare thing. The whole album carries a knotty quality, a twitching, rhythmic sensibility - a “funk” if you will

Rating: 3 out of 5Rating: 3 out of 5Rating: 3 out of 5Rating: 3 out of 5Rating: 3 out of 5

Martin P
Latest Reviews

Paul Bley Trio - Closer
This is one of ESP-DISK’s fiftieth anniversary remasters - and one which I arrive at with no previous knowledge or expectations. The name Paul Bley rings a b...
151021   Watchtower - Control And Resi...
151021   The Collingswood Story - The ...
151021   Haunt - Haunt(Blu Ray)
141021   Sao Paulo Underground & Tuppe...
141021   Fabio Perletta - Un Fiocco D...
141021   Nicola Di Croce - Affective ...
131021   Scarlet Diva - You Were, For ...
121021   Monolithic Torment - It’ll Ge...
121021   Cold War Creatures: Four Film...
111021   15 Degrees Below Zero - Open ...
Latest Articles

SRS Cinema - Purveyors of gorily ...
Since the early 90’s SRS Cinema has been releasing all manner of underground horror, be it gory SOV, general z-budget horror, or low-fi creature featur...
280921   SRS Cinema - Purveyors of gor...
070921   Tine Surel Lange - A Great E...
170821   theNightproduct - Walled Nois...
210721   Martyn Bates / Kodax Strophes...
150621   David Gregory - In The Land O...
270521   Root Cellar, Monolithic Torme...
120521   Patrick Picard - Geek-bound...
150421   Dosis Letalis - Walled Noise ...
170321   Shatraug - Into the Finnish B...
170221   Mark Polonia - Of gore-bound...
Go Up
(c) Musique Machine 2001 -2017. Celebrating 16 years of true independence!! Mail Us at questions=at=musiquemachine=dot=comBottom