Top Bar
Musique Machine Logo Home ButtonReviews ButtonArticles ButtonBand Specials ButtonAbout Us Button
SearchGo Down
Search for  
With search mode in section(s)
And sort the results by
show articles written by  
 Review archive:  # a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

Swans - Leaving Meaning [Young God/ Mute - 2019]

Leaving Meaning is the fifteenth studio album by American alternative legends Swans. The version I shall be reviewing is the longer CD version that runs at over 93 minutes. This version features extended mixes of several songs and an additional track “Some New Things”. It is probably worth noting that the vinyl release runs about ten minutes shorter at around 83 minutes. Having funded the making of Leaving Meaning via the DIY release What Is This? Swans leader Michael Gira was allowed the freedom to record the album he wanted to make without any compromises, and you can really tell with this sprawling work of emotional genius.

First thing first, I have to admit that Leaving Meaning is an album that grows with every listen, to me it encapsulates the band’s sound over the years, and whilst it perhaps doesn’t quite hark back to the truly discordant early 80s industrial material like Filth it takes in pretty much every other era of the band’s existence.

After the short ambient opener “Hum”, “Annaline” kicks things underway easing us in with a mellow opening number that is somewhat reminiscent of Nick Caves last couple of albums. This is followed by “The Hanging Man” a much darker track with that trademark hypnotic groove that they have become known for. This may well be one of the finest songs the band have ever recorded.  It has a sprawling psychedelic vibe that spans the song’s 11 minute length but never outstays its welcome. The reworking of “Amnesia” originally released on 1992s Love of Life is remarkable, it has become a beautifully bleak acoustic ballad. Gira’s lyrics have never sounded more relevant than they do today, and the chorus features a wall of sound that puts Phil Spector to shame. The title track, “Leaving Meaning” sits somewhere between the albums softer more reflective tracks and the hypnotic quality of “The Hanging Man”, building in intensity as it goes. “Sunfucker” is up next, a tribal chant featuring what I believe are the vocal talents of Anna von Hausswolf on backing vocals. “Sunfucker” is a huge slab of discordant alt rock, a masterpiece of krautrock inspired drone rock.

The album’s second half gets underway with “Cathedrals of Heaven” a sizeable chunk of melancholy Americana with a vocal line that harks back to The Doors – My Wild Love from their third album Waiting For the Sun. The song becomes more dissonant towards the end as it builds before finally falling away again at the songs climax. “The Nub” touches on free form jazz in places with astonishing performances from Australian experimental jazz trio The Necks. At just over 12 minutes long it is the longest track on the album and features a host of different layers. Above all else it is a sublime piece of post jazz/rock. “It’s Coming, It’s Real” is another hypnotic monster that fits neatly alongside the others already mentioned, while the CD bonus track “Some New Things” has a very different vibe to everything else on the album, whilst still having that droning hypnotic vibe that Swans have become synonymous with in recent years it feels like a more traditional composition. “What is This?” reminds me of Mercury Rev but on a very heavy downer, whilst the album’s closer “My Phantom Limb” represents a dark dissonant nightmare, harking back to the band’s 80s industrial material to an extent, although nowhere near as harsh as the first few records.

Overall Leaving Meaning is a glorious collision of the various musical styles that make up the Swans back catalogue. Whilst it draws on their 80s and 90s material it is still firmly rooted in the contemporary musical landscape. Michael Gira has created yet another epic slab of gloomy cosmic Americana, that grows on you with every listen. I’ve been invested in this album for several weeks now and it just gets better with every listen. Another forward thinking masterpiece from the legend that is Michael Gira, who is surely one of the greatest artists of all time.

Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5

Darren Charles
Latest Reviews

Swans - Leaving Meaning
Leaving Meaning is the fifteenth studio album by American alternative legends Swans. The version I shall be reviewing is the longer CD version that runs at o...
241225   Wrathchild America - Climbin'...
241225   Rushab Nandha - Tear
241225   Hitcher-Hiker - Hitcher-Hiker...
231225   Devil Fetus - Devil Fetus (B...
221225   Zoltán Huszárik-1963- 1979 ...
201225   Re-Animator - Re-Animator( Bl...
191225   Venus DIE-trap - Venus DIE-tr...
191225   Coyotes - Coyotes(VOD/ Blu Ray)
181225   Various Artists - Santa Is Ro...
181225   Death Ride - Death Ride( DVD)
Latest Articles

Creepy Images Books - Killer Art
Of all the cult/exploitation genres, Giallo stands as one of the more visually & art-based- be it with the grand/ dramatic location, choreographed murder...
231225   Creepy Images Books - Killer Art
221225   Best Of 2025 - Music, Sound &...
041225   The Spectral Sounds of The Pr...
281025   Michael Hurst Interview - Unb...
071025   Xiphos - The Rise And Fall Of...
030925   Third Window Films - A Label ...
130825   HNW fest- Barcelona- 12th Apr...
250725   Raté interview - Walled-in F...
180625   Matthew Holmes - Of razor-sha...
280525   The Residents - Visits From T...
Go Up
(c) Musique Machine 2001 -2025. Twenty four years of true independence!! Mail Us at questions=at=musiquemachine=dot=comBottom