Top Bar
Musique Machine Logo Home ButtonReviews ButtonArticles ButtonBand Specials ButtonAbout Us Button
SearchGo Down
Search for  
With search mode in section(s)
And sort the results by
show articles written by  
 Review archive:  # a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

Dumbsaint ý - Panorama in ten pieces [Birds Robe Records/ Art As Catharsis Records - 2015]

Dumbsaint are an Australian instrumental post metal band who play intricate, powerful and emotional songs that move through a wide variety of moods and ideas.  "Panorama, in ten pieces" is their 3rd album, their debut having been released in 2012.

The thick, high-gain guitar tones, in all their sinuous weight, are similar to Isis and Neurosis.  However, the music is less the war cry of a massive behemoth, and more of an openly sensitive and melancholy emotional expression.  The band borrows rainy, sorrowful moods from vintage black metal, shoegaze and chronically depressive 'autumn' bands like Opeth or Type O Negative.  The chugging riffs are well balanced by highly reverberant siren song leads which are quite Scandinavian, an 'ethereal' guitar style employed by such bands as Katatonia.

Ambition is evident in every aspect of this carefully considered album.  A wide range of influences are explored in a manner which feels natural only because it has been perfectly arranged.  The emotional post-hardcore vibe reminds me of Between the Buried and Me, at times, but unlike BTBAM, Dumbsaint has a strong sense of narrative, incorporating contrasting genres only at the most poignant places within the momentum.  The 'album length song' presentation of the album is very 'progressive rock', as is the fluent movement through a variety of sounds, but there is no stuffiness here.  The band has all the grit and apparent honesty of any noisy underground band.

The riffs change frequently, each immediately gripping with unadorned emotive power.  This album has the power to grab my emotions against my will.  The sense of longing nostalgia is so potent that I find myself transported.  It illicits the same imagery of forests and winter as albums like "In the Nightside Eclipse" did in my younger years, but feels more deeply personal, unafraid to be simply human, in a way I might compare to the melodramatic works of Devin Townsend.  It is reassuring in its poetic interpretation of reality.

The band are clearly avid listeners of music, paying distinct homage to a variety of styles.  The anticipatory, epic tone of Godspeed You Black Emperor, as well as their circular, layered guitar styles, are evident on "Communion".  Alternative rock and 90's groove metal creep into the sound as well, with palm muted staccato breakdowns and minimalist harmonized leads.  The drumming slams hard in adrenaline pumped, stadium pleasing fashion.

I do not particularly miss the human voice as I'm listening to this album, as cheesy and cliched lyrics are often the downfall of music of this kind.

I'm absolutely amazed by the perfection of this album, its emotional impact and flawlessly clever progression through a massive multitude of ideas.  This is one of the best post metal recordings I've heard in my life, on par with any band I've mentioned in this review.

Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5Rating: 5 out of 5

Josh Landry
Latest Reviews

Dumbsaint ý - Panorama in ten pi...
Dumbsaint are an Australian instrumental post metal band who play intricate, powerful and emotional songs that move through a wide variety of moods and ideas...
250226   Fossilization - Advent of Wo...
250226   Hvast - Chwasty Polskie
240226   Dirk Serries - Zonal Disturb...
240226   The Stargazer’s Assistantâ€...
240226   Stephen O‘Malley - Spheres ...
200226   100 Tears - 100 Tears( Blu Ray)
200226   Garden Of Love, - Garden Of L...
200226   Blood Dolls - Blood Dolls( Bl...
190226   Various Artists - So High I'v...
190226   D.A.M. - Inside The Wreckage
Latest Articles

Crude ‘n’ Hope-corroding Wall...
Back in 2024, I got my first taste of Absurd Reality, and I was so impressed by how crude and nasty its take on walled noise was. Behind the project is South...
290126   Crude ‘n’ Hope-corroding ...
231225   Creepy Images Books - Killer Art
221225   Best Of 2025 - Music, Sound &...
041225   The Spectral Sounds of The Pr...
281025   Michael Hurst Interview - Unb...
071025   Xiphos - The Rise And Fall Of...
030925   Third Window Films - A Label ...
130825   HNW fest- Barcelona- 12th Apr...
250725   Raté interview - Walled-in F...
180625   Matthew Holmes - Of razor-sha...
Go Up
(c) Musique Machine 2001 -2025. Twenty four years of true independence!! Mail Us at questions=at=musiquemachine=dot=comBottom